Kashif Hafeez Siddiqui

Who is Our Hero Muhammad Bin Qasim or Raja Dahir ?

In Clsh of Civilizations on April 25, 2010 at 10:17 am

Advertisements
  1. HERE ARE FEW COMMENTS FROM FACE BOOK:
    Zafar Iqbal:
    however the facts are that they dont know the facts…or they are intentionally trying to fool the people
    ..raja dahir was non Sindhi who ruled sindh ,where he imposed Hindu rule over majority (non Hindus.. Buddhists)…local people were oppressed by him . Muhammad bin qasim while coming here to act on the order of governor of Iraq to make release the women ,children and others who while retuning from cylon (sri lanka)were kidnapped by coastallooters,protected by raja dahir.The unpopular raja was defeated with the help of local coastal tribes and MBQ established self rule of local people under his governor.when he left the local people wept and made idols on MBQ and use to consider him as a holy man.
    raja dahir was born near Kashmir…probably north east Punjab…however most of the people considering him as a Sindhi brother which he was not at all. haji sahab is in the same line.. but his jeay sindh comrades have not fully informed…obviously if he knew that raja dahir was Kashmiri or Punjabi….not a Sindhi,…his statement must have been changed….:)
    You must know that nationalists consider arabs as invaders ..haji sbs statment is just an example.
    the details are mentioned in an old history book…chach nama(Persian..translated by allama i.i. Qazi)….to whom most people quote as an authentic source
    however haji sb has right to have any thought and opinion
    Thu at 11:33am ·
    Zahid Pervez very true…..even haji sahib is hindku speaking but igniting pushto nationalism…most jeye sindh leaders are baluch settlers like magsi tribe..mengals behind baluch seperatist movement are barahvi only dravdrens left in pakistan.rest live in south india..
    Thu at 12:47pm ·
    Naufil Shahrukh Zafar bhai, haji adeel jaise log is baat par sharminda hain ke musalman khandan aur pakistan mein kyun paida hogaye. this approach is typical of the so-called nationalists in our country jin ko shayad is baat ki bhi khabar naheen ke nationalism jahan ki paidawar thha wahan us ko dafan kar diya gaya hai aur ab European Unioin (EU) regionalism or trans-national economy ki ek misal hai.
    Btw, you are right ke raja dahir was not a sindhi local. His father, Chach, was a kashmiri brahmin who invaded Sindh and established his rule over the peaceful budhist and jain population. Agar local abadi MBQ ka saath nahin deti tau yeh kaise mumkin thha ke mehez 6000 sipahion ke saath wuh poore sindh, multan aur gujarat ko itni tezi se fatah kar le.
    Haji (Paji) Adeel ko shayad yeh bhi maloom ho ke un ke aur hamaray deegar qaum-paraston ke hero Raja Dahir ka ek aur karnama apne panditon ke mashwaray par apni sagi behen ke saath shadi karna thha.
    Yesterday at 1:31am ·
    Zafar Iqbal @naufil:….. aur yeh shadi iqtidaar bachanay kay liay “maslehatn” kee gaee thee….!!!haji sb is rasm ko dobara na shuroo karwa dain???
    Yesterday at 1:38am ·
    Zafar Iqbal a Pukhtoon friend of mine has commented via emaiL…worth reading:
    AOA: I don’t have words for these types of leaders. I don’t think so he knows the pushtoon history. Pushtoons always attacked India and rule India as well; there is so many names for e.g. Ahmed shaha Abdali, pushtoons usually saying Ahmed Shaha Baba. He attacked India and help Muslims against merhata Hindus. Mr Adeel need to get educated and should read history of Muslims/pushtoons. The peoples like Adeel are the sons of those peoples who were against Pakistan creation (ANP, Jameat-Ulama-e-hind, now Jameat-Ulma-e-Islam or JUI) and now enjoying ruling on our country, they are so thankless peoples. We respect our heroes like Muhammad Bin Qasim, now days we need heroes like him and Traiq Bin Ziyad, Mehmmood Ghaznavee, Doost Muhammad Khan, General Bhakt Khan, Ahmad Shaha Baba and so many others, to help muslims. We don’t need leaders like Mushraf, Hajji Adeel, Mulana Fazal-ur-Rehman or other present leaders. Mr Adeel should now that Pushtoons are Muslims from the last 1400 years and from the last 60 years are Pakistanies. We will live and die for Pakistan. The day will come very soon when Pakistan will be the leader of Islamic world and we will become a practical Muslim country by our well educated young generation with the help of Allah.
    Regrads,
    Idrees Khan
    Canada
    Yesterday at 1:53pm ·
    Zafar Iqbal one more comment from an email group:
    I agree with Mr. Idrees hundered percent. The people like Haji Adeel are the people who dont have knowledge of the history. The people like him should not be allowed to enter the Universities.
    If Muhammad bin Qasim had not come to India I think probably most of the people would be non muslims now a days. People like Muhammad bin Qasim were gift of Allah for South Asian people. If he (Haji Adeel) is writing with his name HAJI, he should think over it with whose efforts and sacrifices???
    Muhammad bin Qasim or Raja Daahir????
    Thanks to Allah the young generation of Pakistan is more knowledgeable now, they know who these people are? Young generation is the future of our beloved country and those days are not far when our country will get back its respect, pride in the nations of the world.
    Wassalam-O-Alaikum Wa Rahmat-Allaah Wa Barakaatuhu
    Liaqat Hussain
    Mobile No. 001 403 969 6921
    Email: liaqat76@gmail.com

    • Our Hero is Muhammad Bini Qasim. Raja Dahir to Kaafir tha ALLAH NI UN KA LIA MUHAMMAD BIN QASIM JAISI MUJAHIS PAIDA KIA. JO DUNYA KI TARIKH MAIN ZINDA RAHA GA. JIS NI BHI YEH KAHA HA KEH RAJA DAHIR HERO HAIN. UN KA EIMAN HE NAHI HA

  2. issi baat se pata chalta hy keh tum logo ny kitna perha hy ! ! !

    raja dahir hamara hero nahi balqe mohammad bin qasim hamara hero hy

    indopak men sub se pehle islam sindh men dakil howa thaa! and sindh iss babul islam

  3. Mari rai main Hoti ko India Bhej dia jai aur Bal Thakre k hawalay kar dia jae phir is ko pata chalay ga k Dahir Ki Aulad Kaisi hai.
    Muhammad Bin Qasim ki jitni zaroorat aaj humain hai shaid us waqat
    nahee thee kun ka humaray mulk ko Zardarioon aur Hotioon ko waisa mard-e-mujahid theek kar sakta hai…

  4. Muhammad Bin Qasim and Raja Dahir are both historical figures. Neither is a hero nor a villain.

    Those who read history to find angels and demons are idiots.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: